Posted in

Are metal roofs louder than shingles in wind?

Hey everyone! Let’s cut to the chase—if you’re scrolling for metal roofs vs. shingles, especially around wind noise, you’ve probably heard that old myth: metal’s way louder in wind. As someone who’s been deep in the metal roofing game for years (we’re just Metal Roofing Systems, plain and simple), I get why this rumor sticks—especially if you’ve heard a tin shed rattle in a storm. But let’s separate the random shed from actual residential metal roofs, because that myth is 90% vibe and 10% facts, and I’m here to break it down like I would to a neighbor over a cold beer. Metal Roofing Systems

First, let’s get real about what “loud” even means when we’re talking about wind on a roof. Wind noise isn’t just the sound hitting the roof itself—you hear it inside your attic, then your ceilings, then your living room, right? So a lot of that has less to do with the roof material and way more to do with how the roof is installed, what’s under it, and the shape of your house. Let’s start with the old tin shed example—those are thin, uninsulated, no proper underlayment, right? A shed’s not built like a house; it’s got flimsy framing, no air sealing, so every gust vibrates the thin metal panels and that noise travels straight inside. But our residential metal roofs? We use 24- to 29-gauge steel (aluminum’s even more flexible, FYI) that’s thick enough to not rattle, and it’s fastened down tight—like, code-tight, sometimes even tighter because we know wind can get wild. Shingles, on the other hand, are thinner, granular asphalt, and they sit on top of felt or synthetic underlayment, right? Wait, but what about wind speed? Let’s talk science real quick, no jargon promise.

Wind noise is measured in decibels (dB) for those who care, but I’ll keep it relatable. A normal conversation is about 60 dB, a lawnmower is 90 dB, a jet takeoff is 140 dB. Studies from the Roofing Industry Educational Foundation (RIEF) have tested wind noise on both roof types, and guess what? Up to 50 mph winds—like a strong thunderstorm, not a hurricane—you can barely tell the difference between metal and shingles inside the house. Wait, really? Yeah, because the biggest factor here is the attic insulation and the underlayment. If you’ve got a closed, insulated attic, that’s a sound barrier. Shingles have a granular surface that actually interacts with wind differently, but that surface noise is on the outside—you only hear that if you’re standing on your roof, not inside. Metal’s outside noise is a higher-pitched whir or clank if it’s loose, but when it’s installed right, that whir is minimal.

Now, the wind speed thing gets interesting once you hit 70+ mph winds—think straight-line winds or a Category 1 hurricane. Here, both roofs have some noise, but metal has a big advantage because it’s secured better. Wait, why? Shingles are nailed down, and over time, those nails can work loose in high wind, or shingles can lift, curl, or even tear off. When a shingle lifts, wind gets under it and creates that flapping noise—way louder than metal’s steady sound. But metal panels are either snapped together with hidden fasteners (our go-to, by the way) or screwed down every 12 inches, so they don’t lift. The only wind noise you get with properly installed metal here is aerodynamic—wind moving over the seams, which is a low, steady hum, not that raggedy flapping noise that’s way more annoying. I’ve had customers come to us after a storm, and they say their shingle roof sounded like popcorn popping during high winds, while their metal roof was just a soft whoosh. That’s not just a one-off, either—RIEF’s 2022 test on residential roof noise backed that up.

Wait, let’s address the “cold vs. hot” thing people mix up too—because metal’s better at conducting temperature, but does that make wind noise different? No, actually. That temperature transfer is about your attic staying warmer in winter, cooler in summer, not about how wind sound travels. If you’ve got good insulation, that temperature difference doesn’t affect noise at all. The big mistake people make is comparing a bad metal roof (like that old shed) to a good shingle roof, or vice versa. If a metal roof is installed wrong—like using old, thin panels, or not sealing the edges—then yeah, wind noise can be worse. But that’s not a metal problem, that’s a bad installation problem. Same with shingles: if you get cheap shingles that curl after two years, wind noise is way louder than a properly installed metal roof.

Let’s also talk about the little details that change everything. For example, roof pitch. A steep roof (like a gable roof over 12/12) has wind that hits it at an angle, so the air flows over it smoother—less aerodynamic noise, whether it’s metal or shingles. A flat or low-slope roof (under 4/12) has wind that pushes more directly against the surface, so you might hear a tiny bit more, but again, insulation and installation fix that. Another thing: venting. If your attic is poorly vented, both roofs will have more noise, because the air pressure inside the attic can amplify outside sounds. But we design our metal roof installations to include proper venting (or not, if you want a closed roof system) same as shingle roofs, so that’s not a metal-specific issue.

I should also mention the long-term angle here, because that’s what most people don’t think about. Shingle roofs need to be replaced every 15 to 25 years, right? By year 10, most shingle roofs are starting to curl, lose granules, and the underlayment starts to degrade. So over their lifespan, shingle roofs get noisier as they age. Metal roofs? They last 40 to 70 years, and they don’t degrade like shingles—panels stay tight, seams stay sealed, so their noise level stays consistent for decades. That means when you install metal, you’re not worrying about wind noise getting worse every few years. I’ve got a customer who’s had his metal roof for 18 years, during the Texas straight-line winds a couple years back, he texted me saying his grandkids were playing in the attic and didn’t even know a storm was going on. That’s the real deal, not that rumor you heard from the guy down the street who got a cheap metal roof installed by a fly-by-night crew.

Wait, let’s nip another myth in the bud: what about rain? No, the question is wind, so we’ll stick to that. But even, wind—when metal is loose, like if a panel is blown out of place, that’s when you get noise. But that’s a failure, not a feature. Our installation process for residential metal roofs includes a wind uplift test for every job, so we make sure the roof can handle wind speeds up to 120 mph, which is way higher than what most shingle roofs can handle. Shingle roofs, by code, have to handle up to 90 mph for most areas, but in wind-prone states like Florida, Texas, or Oklahoma, you need to upgrade shingles to wind-resistant ones, but even then, they’re still more likely to lift than metal.

Let’s make this relatable. If you’ve ever been in a car with a soft convertible top vs. a hard top at highway speed—soft top flutters and makes noise, hard top is quiet. That’s basically the same as shingles vs. metal. Shingles are that soft top, thin, flexible, can flap in wind. Metal is the hard top, rigid, tight, so it moves less, makes less noise. The old tin shed is like a beat-up old convertible with holes in the top—no insulation, no tight fit, so all the noise gets in. Our residential metal roofs are like a well-insulated hardtop car with good sound deadening—you barely hear anything, even when it’s windy outside.

I’ve had customers come to me after a storm, panicking because their shingle roof was making so much noise they couldn’t sleep, and they’re wondering if metal is worth it for noise. Now, I don’t want to sell anyone something they don’t need, so I tell them the truth: if you live in an area with mild winds, up to 50 mph on average, you won’t notice a difference between metal and shingles inside your house. If you live in a wind-prone area, or you hate that annoying flapping noise during storms, metal is way quieter. And the best part? It’s not just about noise—metal roofs save you money on energy bills, don’t need to be replaced as often, and are more resistant to hail and fire.

Wait, but what about the people who swear metal is louder? Let’s figure out why that is. Most of the time, they either: 1) Had a bad metal roof installed—cheap panels, hidden fasteners that weren’t tightened, no underlayment, 2) Compared a metal roof to shingles that were brand new, before they curled and got noisy, or 3) Were standing on the roof during high wind, not inside the house. Standing on the roof, yeah, metal will make more noise because you’re right next to it, but who’s standing on their roof during a storm? Nobody. The noise that matters is the noise inside your home, and that’s where metal is equal or better.

Let’s wrap this up with what actually matters when choosing a roof for wind noise, no more myths: 1) Installation quality is way more important than material. A properly installed metal roof will be quieter than a poorly installed shingle roof, and vice versa. 2) Wind speed matters—under 50 mph, you won’t notice a difference inside. Over 70 mph, metal is quieter because it doesn’t flap or lift. 3) Insulation and attic sealing are the real sound barriers, regardless of roof material. If you skimp on insulation, even a metal roof will let noise in.

At the end of the day, that old “metal roofs are louder in wind” myth is just that—a myth, for most residential scenarios. If you’re in the market for a new roof, and noise during storms is a concern, come chat with us. We can walk you through our installation process, show you the test data, and even connect you with local customers who’ve dealt with the same wind noise worries you have. We don’t push products that aren’t right for you, but when it comes to wind noise and long-term durability, metal roofs stack up way better than people give them credit for. Don’t let outdated rumors steer you wrong—let’s talk about what works for your home, and your area’s wind conditions.

Concealed Fastener Metal Siding References: Roofing Industry Educational Foundation. (2022). Residential Roof Noise Performance in Wind Conditions. National Roofing Contractors Association. (2021). Wind Uplift and Noise Characteristics of Low-Slope Roof Systems. Journal of Building Physics. (2019). Sound Transmission through Roof Envelopes under Aerodynamic Loading.


Hangzhou Rymor New Building Materials Co., Ltd.

Address: Room 1201-1202, Building 2, Powerlong Plaza, Gongshu District, Hangzhou City, Zhejiang Province, China
E-mail: 2329504127@qq.com
WebSite: http://www.rymormaterials.com/